• Paolo Pietro Biancone Department of Management, University of Turin
  • Valerio Brescia Department of Management, University of Turin
  • Michele Oppioli Department of Management, University of Turin


The present research provides a structured literature review of 80 papers on collaborative governance (CG) integration with technologies. The modern concept of CG appears strictly related to new technologies since allowing for more advanced and better communication to increase the efficiency of the activities implemented in the governance process. Although the relevant literature has increased scientific production on the topic, there is a gap in the updated framework describing the technologies that can enhance the deployment of CG. Therefore, the present study employs two distinct theoretical frameworks to analyse the results obtained by applying a rigorous method. The relevant results confirm the implementation of CG in different contexts, such as smart cities and healthcare. Consistent with classical theory, it analyses the role of stakeholders as public and private entities, such as companies, organizations, and citizens. In addition, the paper focuses on technologies and stakeholder relationships to implement actions to increase the public value of organizational capacity. Finally, the research proposes a future research agenda to contribute to the emerging argument that sees technologies adopted in the CG approach to support the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs).

Author Biographies

Paolo Pietro Biancone, Department of Management, University of Turin

Full professor

Valerio Brescia, Department of Management, University of Turin


Michele Oppioli, Department of Management, University of Turin

Phd Student


Aberbach, Joel D, and Tom Christensen. 2005. ‘Citizens and Consumers’. Public Management Review 7 (2): 225–46.

Agarwal, N., C. Soh, and A. Yeow. 2022. ‘Managing Paradoxical Tensions in the Development of a Telemedicine System’. Information and Organization 32 (1).

Alford, John, and Janine O’Flynn. 2009. ‘Making Sense of Public Value: Concepts, Critiques and Emergent Meanings’. International Journal of Public Administration 32 (3–4): 171–91.

Al-Sobhi, F., V. Weerakkody, and M. Al-Busaidy. 2010. ‘‘The roles of intermediaries’. Proceedings of AMCIS 2010.

Andonova, L.B. 2010. ‘Public-Private Partnerships for the Earth: Politics and Patterns of Hybrid Authority in the Multilateral System’. Global Environmental Politics 10 (2): 25–53.

Andonova, Liliana. 2010. ‘Public-Private Partnerships for the Earth: Politics and Patterns of Hybrid Authority in the Multilateral System’. Global Environmental Politics 10 (May): 25–53.

Andranovich, Greg. 1995. ‘Achieving Consensus in Public Decision Making: Applying Interest-Based Problem Solving to the Challenges of Intergovernmental Collaboration’. The Journal of Applied Behavioral Science 31 (December): 429–45.

Andrews, James. 2003. ‘An Author Co-Citation Analysis of Medical Informatics’. Journal of the Medical Library Association : JMLA 91 (February): 47–56.

Ansell, C., and A. Gash. 2008. ‘Collaborative Governance in Theory and Practice’. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory 18 (4): 543–71.

Ansell, Chris, and Alison Gash. 2018. ‘Collaborative Platforms as a Governance Strategy’. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory 28 (1): 16–32.

Aria, Massimo, and Corrado Cuccurullo. 2017. ‘Bibliometrix: An R-Tool for Comprehensive Science Mapping Analysis’. Journal of Informetrics 11 (4): 959–75.

Barandiarán, X., N. Restrepo, and Á. Luna. 2019. ‘Collaborative Governance in Tourism: Lessons from Etorkizuna Eraikiz in the Basque Country, Spain’. Tourism Review 74 (4): 902–14.

Batory, Agnes, and Sara Svensson. 2019. ‘The Fuzzy Concept of Collaborative Governance: A Systematic Review of the State of the Art’. Central European Journal of Public Policy 13 (2): 28–39.

Bernardi, M., and D. Diamantini. 2018. ‘Shaping the Sharing City: An Exploratory Study on Seoul and Milan’. Journal of Cleaner Production 203: 30–42.

Bolívar, M.P.R. 2018. ‘Creative Citizenship: The New Wave for Collaborative Environments in Smart Cities [La Ciudadanía Creativa: La Nueva Onda Para Entornos Colaborativos En Ciudades Inteligentes]’. Academia Revista Latinoamericana de Administracion 31 (1): 277–302.

Box, Richard C. 1999. ‘Running Government Like a Business: Implications for Public Administration Theory and Practice’. The American Review of Public Administration 29 (1): 19–43.

Brinkerhoff, Derick W. 1999. ‘Exploring State–Civil Society Collaboration: Policy Partnerships in Developing Countries’. Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly 28 (1_suppl): 59–86.

Chellappa, Ramnath K. 2008. ‘Consumers’ Trust in Electronic Commerce Transactions: The Role of Perceived Privacy and Perceived Security’, 38.

Chen, Guo, and Lu Xiao. 2016. ‘Selecting Publication Keywords for Domain Analysis in Bibliometrics: A Comparison of Three Methods’. Journal of Informetrics 10 (1): 212–23.

Chen, Y.-C., and J. Lee. 2018. ‘Collaborative Data Networks for Public Service: Governance, Management, and Performance’. Public Management Review 20 (5): 672–90.

Chrislip, David D., and Carl E. Larson. 1994. Collaborative Leadership : How Citizens and Civic Leaders Can Make a Difference. 1. ed., 1. print. An American Leadership Forum Book. San Francisco, Calif. : Jossey-Bass.

Cooper, Terry, Thomas Bryer, and Jack Meek. 2006. ‘Citizen-Centered Collaborative Public Management’. Thomas A Bryer 66 (December).

Criado, J.I., and A. Guevara-Gómez. 2021. ‘Public Sector, Open Innovation, and Collaborative Governance in Lockdown Times. A Research of Spanish Cases during the COVID-19 Crisis’. Transforming Government: People, Process and Policy 15 (4): 612–26.

Dawes, Sharon S., Anthony M. Cresswell, and Theresa A. Pardo. 2009. ‘From “Need to Know” to “Need to Share”: Tangled Problems, Information Boundaries, and the Building of Public Sector Knowledge Networks’. Public Administration Review 69 (3): 392–402.

Ebrahim, Zakareya, and Zahir Irani. 2005. ‘E‐government Adoption: Architecture and Barriers’. Business Process Management Journal 11 (5): 589–611.

Emerson, K., T. Nabatchi, and S. Balogh. 2012. ‘An Integrative Framework for Collaborative Governance’. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory 22 (1): 1–29.

Feng, Y., and P. Yang. 2020. ‘Innovative Application of Environmental Pollution Control in the Background of Big Data of Business Economy’. Fresenius Environmental Bulletin 29 (2): 1063–74.

Flak, Leif Skiftenes, and Jeremy Rose. 2005. ‘Stakeholder Governance: Adapting Stakeholder Theory to the E-Government Field’. Communications of the Association for Information Systems 16: 642-664.

Franco, I.B., J.A.P. de Oliveira, and S.H. Ali. 2018. ‘Peace with Hunger: Colombia’s Checkered Experience with Post-Conflict Sustainable Community Development in Emerald-Mining Regions’. Sustainability (Switzerland) 10 (2).

Friedman, C.P., I. Iakovidis, L. Debenedetti, and N.M. Lorenzi. 2009. ‘Across the Atlantic Cooperation to Address International Challenges in EHealth and Health IT: Managing toward a Common Goal’. International Journal of Medical Informatics 78 (11): 778–84.

Garavaglia, C., A. Sancino, and B. Trivellato. 2021. ‘Italian Mayors and the Management of COVID-19: Adaptive Leadership for Organizing Local Governance’. Eurasian Geography and Economics 62 (1): 76–92.

Gerlak, A.K., and T. Heikkila. 2011. ‘Building a Theory of Learning in Collaboratives: Evidence from the Everglades Restoration Program’. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory 21 (4): 619–44.

Gilman, Hollie. 2017. ‘Civic Tech For Urban Collaborative Governance’. PS: Political Science & Politics 50 (July): 744–50.

Gordon, E., J. Harlow, M. Teng, and E. Christoferetti. 2021. ‘Toward A Collaborative Smart City: A Play-Based Urban Living Laboratory in Boston’. International Journal of Human-Computer Interaction.

Guerrero, P., M.S. Møller, A.S. Olafsson, and B. Snizek. 2016. ‘Revealing Cultural Ecosystem Services through Instagram Images: The Potential of Social Media Volunteered Geographic Information for Urban Green Infrastructure Planning and Governance’. Urban Planning 1 (2): 1–17.

Gunton, Thomas, and J.C. Day. 2003. ‘The Theory and Practice of Collaborative Planning in Resource and Environmental Management’. Environments 31 (January): 5–20.

Heeks, Richard. 2003. ‘Most EGovernment-for- Development Projects Fail’:, 19.

Hwang, S. 2017. ‘Collaborative Governance and Information Technology Innovation: Public–Nonprofit Partnerships to Build Neighborhood Information Systems’. International Review of Public Administration 22 (4): 321–43.

Imperial, Mark T. 2005. ‘Using Collaboration as a Governance Strategy: Lessons From Six Watershed Management Programs’. Administration & Society 37 (3): 281–320.

Kallis, G., M. Kiparsky, and R. Norgaard. 2009. ‘Collaborative Governance and Adaptive Management: Lessons from California’s CALFED Water Program’. Environmental Science and Policy 12 (6): 631–43.

Kapucu, Naim. 2010. ‘CollaborativePublicManagementandGovernanceFinalforEJEPS.Pdf’, May.

Kelly, J., T. Sadeghieh, and K. Adeli. 2014. ‘Peer review in scientific publications: Benefits, critiques, & a survival guide’. EJIFCC 25 (3): 227–43.

Klievink, B., H. Van Der Voort, and W. Veeneman. 2018. ‘Creating Value through Data Collaboratives: Balancing Innovation and Control’. Information Polity 23 (4): 379–97.

Kou, P., Y. Han, X. Qi, and Y. Li. 2021. ‘Does China’s Policy of Carbon Emission Trading Deliver Sulfur Dioxide Reduction Co-Benefits?’ Environment, Development and Sustainability.

Kuhn, B.M. 2018. ‘China’s Commitment to the Sustainable Development Goals: An Analysis of Push and Pull Factors and Implementation Challenges’. Chinese Political Science Review 3 (4): 359–88.

Lang, A. 2019. ‘Collaborative Governance in Health and Technology Policy: The Use and Effects of Procedural Policy Instruments’. Administration and Society 51 (2): 272–98.

Lasker, Roz D., and Elisa S. Weiss. 2003. ‘Broadening Participation in Community Problem Solving: A Multidisciplinary Model to Support Collaborative Practice and Research’. Journal of Urban Health: Bulletin of the New York Academy of Medicine 80 (1): 14–47; discussion 48-60.

Lee, T.D., H. Park, and J. Lee. 2019. ‘Collaborative Accountability for Sustainable Public Health: A Korean Perspective on the Effective Use of ICT-Based Health Risk Communication’. Government Information Quarterly 36 (2): 226–36.

Liu, G., and X. Chen. 2020. ‘Smart Home System Based on Embedded Control and Wireless Communication’. In Proceedings - 2020 International Conference on Intelligent Transportation, Big Data and Smart City, ICITBS 2020, 547–50. Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers Inc.

Liu, J., S. Liu, X. Xu, and Q. Zou. 2022. ‘Can Digital Transformation Promote the Rapid Recovery of Cities from the COVID-19 Epidemic? An Empirical Analysis from Chinese Cities’. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 19 (6).

Liu, T., X. Yang, and Y. Zheng. 2020. ‘Understanding the Evolution of Public–Private Partnerships in Chinese e-Government: Four Stages of Development’. Asia Pacific Journal of Public Administration 42 (4): 222–47.

Liu, Z., L. Ma, T. Huang, and H. Tang. 2020. ‘Collaborative Governance for Responsible Innovation in the Context of Sharing Economy: Studies on the Shared Bicycle Sector in China’. Journal of Open Innovation: Technology, Market, and Complexity 6 (2).

Looman, W., V. Struckmann, J. Köppen, E. Baltaxe, T. Czypionka, M. Huic, J. Pitter, et al. 2021. ‘Drivers of Successful Implementation of Integrated Care for Multi-Morbidity: Mechanisms Identified in 17 Case Studies from 8 European Countries’. Social Science and Medicine 277.

Luftman, J., K. Lyytinen, and T.B. Zvi. 2017. ‘Enhancing the Measurement of Information Technology (IT) Business Alignment and Its Influence on Company Performance’. Journal of Information Technology 32 (1): 26–46.

Ma, Y., T.F. Thornton, D. Mangalagiu, J. Lan, D. Hestad, E.A. Cappello, and S. Van der Leeuw. 2020. ‘Co-Creation, Co-Evolution and Co-Governance: Understanding Green Businesses and Urban Transformations’. Climatic Change 160 (4): 621–36.

Mah, Daphne Ngar-Yin, and Peter Hills. 2014. ‘Collaborative Governance for Technological Innovation: A Comparative Case Study of Wind Energy in Xinjiang, Shanghai, and Guangdong’. Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy 32 (3): 509–29.

Mali, Nidhi Vij, and J. Ramon Gil-Garcia. 2017. ‘Individual Empowerment through Digital Governance: Proposing an Assessment Framework for India’. In Proceedings of the Special Collection on EGovernment Innovations in India, 140–45. ICEGOV ’17. New York, NY, USA: Association for Computing Machinery.

Malodia, Suresh, Amandeep Dhir, Mahima Mishra, and Zeeshan Ahmed Bhatti. 2021. ‘Future of E-Government: An Integrated Conceptual Framework’. Technological Forecasting and Social Change 173 (December): 121102.

Massaro, Maurizio, John Dumay, and James Guthrie. 2016. ‘On the Shoulders of Giants: Undertaking a Structured Literature Review in Accounting’. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal 29 (5): 767–801.

Meijer, A., and M.P.R. Bolívar. 2016. ‘Governing the Smart City: A Review of the Literature on Smart Urban Governance’. International Review of Administrative Sciences 82 (2): 392–408.

Meijer, A., and M. Thaens. 2018. ‘Quantified Street: Smart Governance of Urban Safety’. Information Polity 23 (1): 29–41.

Molnár, A., and S. Svensson. 2022. ‘Collaboration and Policy Making in Adaptation Planning: The Impact of a Boundary Organization in Hungary’. International Journal of Climate Change: Impacts and Responses 14 (2): 49–63.

Moreno-Jiménez, J.M., C. Pérez-Espés, and M. Velázquez. 2014. ‘E-Cognocracy and the Design of Public Policies’. Government Information Quarterly 31 (1): 185–94.

North, Peter. 2000. ‘Is There Space for Organisation from Below within the UK Government’s Action Zones? A Test of “Collaborative Planning”’. Urban Studies 37 (8): 1261–78.

Nour, Mohamed A., AbdelRahman A. AbdelRahman, and Adam Fadlalla. 2008. ‘A Context-Based Integrative Framework for e-Government Initiatives’. Government Information Quarterly 25 (3): 448–61.

Nurlybaeva, G. 2021. ‘The Creation of International Collaborative Governance Discourse during the Process of Teaching Vocabulary at the University’. Teaching Public Administration.

Onitsuka, K., K. Ninomiya, and S. Hoshino. 2018. ‘Potential of 3D Visualization for Collaborative Rural Landscape Planning with Remote Participants’. Sustainability (Switzerland) 10 (9).

Park, C.H., and K. Kim. 2022. ‘Exploring the Effects of the Adoption of the Open Government Partnership: A Cross-Country Panel Data Analysis’. Public Performance and Management Review.

Pine, Barbara A., Robin Warsh, and Anthony N. Maluccio. 1998. ‘Participatory Management in a Public Child Welfare Agency’. Administration in Social Work 22 (1): 19–32.

Purdy, Jill M. 2012. ‘A Framework for Assessing Power in Collaborative Governance Processes’. Public Administration Review 72 (3): 409–17.

Putra, A.L., J. Martinez, and J. Verplanke. 2020. ‘Integrating Climate Service Co-Production into Spatial Planning in Jakarta’. International Journal of Urban Sustainable Development.

Rogers, E., and E.P. Weber. 2010. ‘Thinking Harder about Outcomes for Collaborative Governance Arrangements’. American Review of Public Administration 40 (5): 546–67.

Romanelli, M. 2020. ‘Analysing the Role of Information Technology towards Sustainable Cities Living’. Kybernetes 49 (7): 2037–52.

Schneider, G. 2020. ‘Designing Pro-Competitive Research Data Pools: Which EU Competition Remedies for Research Data Silos in Digital Markets?’ Yearbook of Antitrust and Regulatory Studies 13 (21): 161–86.

Scott, Charity. 2011. ‘A Case Study in Collaborative Governance: Health Care Law Reform in Georgia’. Conflict Resolution Quarterly 28 (4): 441–63.

Secinaro, Silvana, Valerio Brescia, Davide Calandra, and Paolo Biancone. 2020. ‘Employing Bibliometric Analysis to Identify Suitable Business Models for Electric Cars’. Journal of Cleaner Production 264 (August): 121503.

Selzer, M., J.L. Jonas, V. Pebbles, S. Kosek-Sills, and J.W. Allan. 2020. ‘Crossing Boundaries between Science and Policy: Two Case Studies Illustrate the Importance of Boundary Organizations in the Great Lakes Basin’. Journal of Great Lakes Research 46 (4): 933–46.

Skelcher, Chris, and Steven Rathgeb Smith. 2015. ‘Theorizing Hybridity: Institutional Logics, Complex Organizations, and Actor Identities: The Case of Nonprofits’. Public Administration 93 (2): 433–48.

Sørensen, Eva, Peter Triantafillou, and Bodil Damgaard. 2015. ‘Governing EU Employment Policy: Does Collaborative Governance Scale Up?’ Policy & Politics 43 (3): 331–47.

Sun, H., Z. Zhang, and Z. Liu. 2022. ‘Does Air Pollution Collaborative Governance Promote Green Technology Innovation? Evidence from China’. Environmental Science and Pollution Research.

The General Assembly - United Nations. 2015. ‘Transforming Our World the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development.Pdf’.

Ulibarri, Nicola. 2015. ‘Tracing Process to Performance of Collaborative Governance: A Comparative Case Study of Federal Hydropower Licensing’. Policy Studies Journal 43 (2): 283–308.

Vangen, Siv, and Chris Huxham. 2003a. ‘Enacting Leadership for Collaborative Advantage: Dilemmas of Ideology and Pragmatism in the Activities of Partnership Managers’. British Journal of Management 14 (s1): S61–76.

———. 2003b. ‘Nurturing Collaborative Relations: Building Trust in Interorganizational Collaboration’. The Journal of Applied Behavioral Science 39 (March): 5–31.

Warner, Jeroen F. 2006. ‘More Sustainable Participation? Multi-Stakeholder Platforms for Integrated Catchment Management’. International Journal of Water Resources Development 22 (1): 15–35.

Weech-Maldonado, R., and S. B. Merrill. 2000. ‘Building Partnerships with the Community: Lessons from the Camden Health Improvement Learning Collaborative’. Journal of Healthcare Management / American College of Healthcare Executives 45 (3): 189–205.

Welch, E.W., C.C. Hinnant, and M.J. Moon. 2005. ‘Linking Citizen Satisfaction with E-Government and Trust in Government’. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory 15 (3): 371–91.

West, Darrell M. 2004. ‘E-Government and the Transformation of Service Delivery and Citizen Attitudes’. Public Administration Review 64 (1): 15–27.

Xue, Z., Y. Zheng, and J. Hu. 2022. ‘Cross-Departmental Collaboration within the Government in China: The Case of Shanghai’. China: An International Journal 20 (1): 73–92.

Yan, Y., X. Zhang, J. Zhang, and K. Li. 2020. ‘Emissions Trading System (ETS) Implementation and Its Collaborative Governance Effects on Air Pollution: The China Story’. Energy Policy 138.

Yang, L. 2018. ‘Collaborative Knowledge-Driven Governance: Types and Mechanisms of Collaboration between Science, Social Science, and Local Knowledge’. Science and Public Policy 45 (1): 53–73.

Yang, L., and C. Li. 2015. ‘Types and Mechanisms of Science-Driven Institutional Change: The Case of Desertification Control in Northern China’. Environmental Policy and Governance 25 (1): 16–35.

Yi, M., Y. Lu, L. Wen, Y. Luo, S. Xu, and T. Zhang. 2022. ‘Whether Green Technology Innovation Is Conducive to Haze Emission Reduction: Empirical Evidence from China’. Environmental Science and Pollution Research 29 (8): 12115–27.

Zhao, D., and D. Wang. 2019. ‘The Research of Tripartite Collaborative Governance on Disorderly Parking of Shared Bicycles Based on the Theory of Planned Behavior and Motivation Theories-a Case of Beijing, China’. Sustainability (Switzerland) 11 (19).

Zhao, Fang, and M. Sajid Khan. 2013. ‘An Empirical Study of E-Government Service Adoption: Culture and Behavioral Intention’. International Journal of Public Administration 36 (10): 710–22.

Zhou, Kevin Zheng, Chi Kin (Bennett) Yim, and David K. Tse. 2005. ‘The Effects of Strategic Orientations on Technology- and Market-Based Breakthrough Innovations’. Journal of Marketing 69 (2): 42–60.

Ziervogel, G., L. Pasquini, and S. Haiden. 2017. ‘Nodes and Networks in the Governance of Ecosystem-Based Adaptation: The Case of the Bergrivier Municipality, South Africa’. Climatic Change 144 (2): 271–85.

Ziervogel, G., J. Waddell, W. Smit, and A. Taylor. 2016. ‘Flooding in Cape Town’s Informal Settlements: Barriers to Collaborative Urban Risk Governance’. South African Geographical Journal 98 (1): 1–20.

Zupic, Ivan, and Tomaž Čater. 2015. ‘Bibliometric Methods in Management and Organization’. Organizational Research Methods 18 (3): 429–72.

Zwickle, A., B.C. Feltman, A.J. Brady, A.D. Kendall, and D.W. Hyndman. 2021. ‘Sustainable Irrigation through Local Collaborative Governance: Evidence for a Structural Fix in Kansas’. Environmental Science and Policy 124: 517–26.




How to Cite

Biancone, P. P., Brescia, V., & Oppioli, M. (2023). COLLABORATIVE GOVERNANCE AND TECHNOLOGIES: A BIBLIOMETRIC ANALYSIS. International Public Management Review, 22(1), 46–76. Retrieved from