The efficiency score as an indicator of the appropriateness of public spending. A pilot study in Italian Metropolitan Cities.

Authors

  • Marco Benvenuto
  • Luca Notarangelo
  • Carmine Viola
  • Chiara Aufiero UNIVERSITY OF SALENTO

Keywords:

Data Envelopment Analysis, Decision Making, Efficiency, Metropolitan Cities, Performance Management

Abstract

The management of economic and financial resources is a topic of great interest within public administrations. Measuring the efficiency of public resource utilization is complex because the analysis of processes through planning, programming, and control systems varies depending on the diverse needs of the community. Recently, the concept of public value has led to the testing of measurement systems aimed at achieving synthetic values capable of guiding decision governance towards the optimal use of resources. The criterion of efficiency in public administrations is more problematic than it may appear because efficiency has become synonymous with cost minimization. It is known that such an example does not represent efficiency because what sense would it make to minimize costs in the production of a service for something that is not desired? The notion of efficiency requires a relationship between means (inputs) and ends (outputs/outcomes). The goal of this work is to identify the relationships between means and ends to introduce synthetic indicators, "efficiency scores," of public spending based on the budget data of Italian "metropolitan cities" over the period 2019-2022. The results represent a new evaluation metric to support decision-makers in achieving strategic objectives over time.

References

Afonso, A. and Fernandes, S. 2006. ‘’Measuring local government spending efficiency: evidence for the Lisbon region.’’ Regional Studies, 40, 1, 39–53.

Afonso, A. and Fernandes, S. 2008. ‘’Assessing and explaining the relative efficiency of local government.’’ Journal of Socio-Economics, 37 (5), pp. 1946-1979.

Afonso, A. and Jalles, J.T. and Venâncio, A. 2023. ‘’Government spending efficiency, measurement, and applications: a cross-country efficiency dataset’’, pp 48-60.

Afonso, A., & Fernandes, S. 2008. Assessing the efficiency of local gov-ernment services: An application to Portuguese municipalities. Public Administration Review, 68(2), 371-383.

Afonso, A., and Leal, F.S. 2019. ‘’Fiscal multipliers in the Eurozone: a SVAR analysis.’’ Applied Economics, 51(51), 5577–5593.

Afonso, A., Schuknecht, L., and Tanzi, V. 2005. ‘’Public Sector Efficiency: An International Comparison’’. Public Choice, 123 (3-4), pp. 321-347.

Agasisti, T. and Porcelli, F. 2022. ‘’Local Governments Efficiency and Its Heterogeneity – Empirical Evidence from a Stochastic Frontier Analysis of Italian Municipalities 2010- 2018.’’ Applied Economics 1–26.

Agasisti, T., & Porcelli, F. 2022. Efficiency in local government services: An analysis of the Italian case. International Journal of Public Sector Man-agement, 35(3), 337-355.

Agasisti, T., Dal Bianco, A., and Griffini, M. 2015. ‘’The public sector fiscal efficiency in Italy: the case of Lombardy municipalities in the provision of the essential public services.’’ Technical report, Società Italiana di Economia Pubblica.

Akkan, C., Karadayi, M. A., Ekinci, Y., Ülengin, F., Uray, N., & Karaosmanoğlu, E. (2020). Efficiency analysis of emergency depart-ments in metropolitan areas. Socio-Economic Planning Sciences, 69, 100679.

Alford, J. (2016). Co-Production, interdependence and publicness: Extend-ing public service-dominant logic. Public Management Review, 673–691.

Arcelus, F.J., Arocena, P., Cabasés F., and Pascual P. 2015. ‘’On the Cost-Efficiency of Service Delivery in Small Municipalities.’’ Regional stud-ies 49 (9): 1469–1480

Aristovnik, A. and Obadić, A. 2015. ‘’The impact and efficiency of public administration excellence on fostering SMEs in EU countries.’’

Balaguer-Coll, M.T. and Prior, D. 2009. ‘’Short-and long-term evaluation of efficiency and quality. An application to Spanish municipalities.’’ Ap-plied Economics 41, 23, 2991–3002.

Balaguer-Coll, M.T., Prior, D. and Tortosa-Ausina, E. 2013. ‘’Output com-plexity, environmental conditions, and the efficiency of municipalities.’’ Journal of Productivity Analysis 39, 3, 303–324.

Barone, G. and Mocetti, S. 2011. ‘’Tax morale and public spending ineffi-ciency.’’ International Tax and Public Finance 18, 6, 724–749.

Barra, C., Lagravinese R. and Zotti, R. 2022. ‘’Exploring Hospital Efficien-cy Within and Between Italian Regions: New Empirical Evidence.’’ Journal of Productivity Analysis 57 (3): 269– 284.

Bartsits, I., Sidorenko, E. and Khisamova, Z. 2019. ‘’The efficiency of digi-tal public administration assessing: theoretical and applied aspects.’’

Batalli, M. 2011. ‘’Impact of public administration innovations on enhancing the citizens' expectations.’’

Benito-López, B., Moreno M.R. and Solana-Ibañez J. 2011. ‘’Determinants of efficiency in the provision of municipal street-cleaning and refuse collection services.’’ Waste Manag. 31(6):1099-108.

Benito-López, B., Solana, J. and Moreno, M.R. 2015. ‘’Explaining efficien-cy in municipal services providers.’’ Journal of Productivity Analysis 42, 3, 225–239.

Benvenuto, M., Aufiero, C., & Viola, C. (2023). A systematic literature re-view on the determinants of sustainability reporting systems. Heliyon, 9(4).

Bernal González, I., Flores, A.J., and Herrero Maritza, A. 2023. ‘’Impact of intellectual capital on the performance of public administration.’’

Bobbio, L. (2019). Governare le aree metropolitane in Italia: sfide e prospet-tive. Studi regionali, 53 (6), 880-892

Boetti, L. Piacenza, M. and Turati, G, 2011. ‘’La valutazione dell’efficienza globale dell'attività dei governi locali.’’ Working Paper n.1/2011, HERMES, Centro di Ricerca sull’Economia e il Diritto dei Servizi Regolamentati, Fondazione Collegio Carlo Alberto.

Boetti, L., Piacenza, M. and Turati, G. 2010. ‘’Decentralization and local government’s performance: how does fiscal autonomy affect spending efficiency?’’ Department of Economics and Public Finance “G. Prato”, University of Turin, Working Paper Series.

Bosch, N., Pedraja, F. and Suàrez-Pandiello, J. 2000. ‘’Measuring the effi-ciency of Spanish municipal refuse collection services.’’ Local Govern-ment Studies 26, 3, 71-90.

Bosch-Roca, N., Mora-Corral, A.J., and Espasa-Queralt, M. 2012. ‘’Citizen control and the efficiency of local public services.’’ Environment and Planning C 30, 2, 248.

Bucci, V., Ferrara, G., and Resce, G. 2023. ‘’Local government spending ef-ficiency and fiscal decentralization: evidence from Italian municipali-ties.’’

Buleca, J. and Mura, L. 2014. ‘’Quantification of the efficiency of public administration by data envelopment analysis.’’

Cabral, S., Mahoney, J. T., McGahan, A. M., & Potoski, M. (2019). Value creation and value appropriation in public and nonprofit organizations. Strategic Management Journal, 465–475.

Camagni, R., & Capello, R. (2017). Sistemi metropolitani e performance economica: evidenze da città europee e italiane. Journal of Regional Science, 57 (2), 269-290.

Carosi, L., D’Inverno, G. and Ravagli, L. 2014. ‘’Global public spending ef-ficiency in Tuscan municipalities.’’ Technical report, Dipartimento di Economia e Management (DEM), University of Pisa, Italy.

Cecot, C. 2023. ‘’Efficiency and Equity in Regulation’’ 76 Vanderbilt Law Re-view, 2023.

Cepiku, D., Hinna, A., Scarozza, D. and Bonomi Savignon A. 2017. ‘’Per-formance information use in public administration: an exploratory study of determinants and effects. Journal of Management & Governance, Springer;’’ Accademia Italiana di Economia Aziendale (AIDEA), vol. 21(4), pages 963-991

Cepiku, D., Mussari, R. and Giordano, F. 2016. ‘’Local governments man-aging austerity: approaches, determinants, and impact.’’ Public admin-istration, 94: 223-243.

Charnes, A., Cooper, W.W. and Rhodes, E. 1978. ‘’Measuring the efficien-cy of decision-making units.’’ European Journal of Operational Re-search 2, 6, 429–444.

Christopher Lee, C., Langdo, J., Hwang, D., Marques, V. and Hwang, P. 2023. ‘’Impacts of distributors and group purchasing organizations on hospital efficiency and profitability: a bilateral data envelopment analy-sis model.’’

Cleaud, G., Lemoine, M. and Pionnier, P.A. 2014. ‘’Which Size and Evolu-tion of the Government Expenditure Multiplier in France (1980-2010)?’’ (SSRN Scholarly Paper No. ID 2374368). Rochester, NY: Social Sci-ence Research Network.

Conrad, A. Neuberger, D. and Trigo Gamarra, L. 2009. ‘’The impact of re-gional and demographic factors on the efficiency of German savings banks”, Thu¨nen- series of applied economic theory, 111.

Cooper, W.W., Li, S., Seiford, L.M. and Zhu, J. 2011. ‘’Sensitivity analysis in DEA. In Cooper, WW, Seiford, LM, Zhu, J. (Eds.) “Handbook on data envelopment analysis”, pp. 41-70, Springer US.

D.lgs n. 118/2011.

D’Inverno, G., Carosi, L., and Ravagli, L. 2018. ‘’Global public spending efficiency in Tuscan municipalities.’’ Socio-Economic Planning Scienc-es, Volume 61, pp. 102-113.

De Borger, B. and Kerstens, K. 1996. ‘’Cost efficiency of Belgian local governments: A comparative analysis of FDH, DEA, and econometric approaches," Regional Science and Urban Economics, Elsevier, vol. 26(2), pp.145-170.

De Simone, E., Bonasia, M., Gaeta, G.L., and Cicatiello, L. 2019. ‘’The ef-fect of fiscal transparency on government spending efficiency.’’ Journal of Economic Studies, Vol. 46 No. 7, pp. 1365-1379.

De Witte, K. and Geys, B. 2009. ‘’The political economy of efficient public good provision: evidence from Flemish libraries using a generalised conditional efficiency framework, Leuven: Center for Economic Stud-ies, Discussion Paper Series 9.10.’’

Deidda Gagliardo, E. 2015. ‘’Il valore pubblico. La nuova frontiera delle perfor-mance’’ RIREA.

Deidda Gagliardo, E., & Saporito, R. (2021). Il Piao come strumento di pro-grammazione integrata per la creazione di Valore pubblico. Rivista Ital-iana di Public Management, 4(2), 196-236.

Deidda Gagliardo, E., Papi, L., Gobbo, G., Ievoli, R., & Francesconi, A. (2023). La qualità dei PIAO nelle “Mega” Università: come program-mare in modo semplificato, selettivo, adeguato, integrato e funzionale alla creazione e alla protezione di Valore Pubblico. Azienda Pubblica, 2023(2), 131-156.

Dipartimento della Funzione Pubblica, 2017. Linee guida n. 2/2017. Presidenza del Consiglio dei Ministri

Dolynska, O. and Shorobura, I. 2023. ‘’Leadership in public administration: to-day's challenges.’’

Donati, D. (2023). Città strategiche: l’amministrazione dell’area metropoli-tana (p. 296). FrancoAngeli.

Doumpos, M. and Cohen, S. 2014. ‘’Applying data envelopment analysis on accounting data to assess and optimize the efficiency of Greek local gov-ernments.’’ Omega; 46:74e85.

Farrell, M.J. 1957. ‘’The Measurement of Productive Efficiency. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society.’’ Series A (General), 120(3), 253–290.

Feldstein M. 1967. ‘’Economic Analysis for Health Service Efficiency: Econ-ometric Studies of the British National Health Service. Amsterdam: North-Holland Publishing Company.’’

Florano, ER (2020). Pianificazione della continuità del settore pubblico: preparazione della burocrazia nell’era della nuova “Normalità”. Interna-tional Public Management Review , 19 (2), 89–114.

Forum PA. (2023). PIAO: Cos’è il Piano Integrato di Attività e Or-ganizzazione e cosa cambia per le Pubbliche Amministrazioni.

Francisco Pinheiro Catalão, F., Oliveira Cruz, C., Sarmento, J.M. 2022. ‘’Pub-lic management and cost overruns in public projects.’’

García Sánchez, I.M. 2006a. ‘’Efficiency measurement in Spanish local gov-ernment: the case of municipal water services.’’ Review of Policy Research 23, 2, 355–372.

García Sánchez, I.M. 2006b. ‘’Estimation of the effect of environmental con-ditions on technical efficiency: the case of fire services.’’ Revue d’Économie Régionale & Urbaine, 4, 597–614.

García, J.M., Rueda-López, N. and De Pablo-Valenciano, J. 2022. ‘’Local government efficiency: reviewing determinants and setting new trends.’’

Geys, B., Heinemann, F. and Kalb, A. 2013. ‘’Local government efficiency in German municipalities.’’ Raumforschung und Raumordnung 71, 4, 283–293.

Golini, A. 2001. ‘’Alcune rapide riflessioni in tema di indagini longitudinali nel demografico e nel sociale’’. Franco Angeli.

Grandy, C. 2009. ‘’The “efficient” public administrator: Pareto and a well‐rounded approach to public administration.’’ Public Administration Re-view, vol. 69, no. 6, pp. 1115–23.

Guthrie, J., Domingues, A.R., Manes-Rossi, F. and Orelli, R.L. 2020. ‘’Inte-grated reporting and sustainable development goals in universities. In Handbook of Integrated Reporting.’’

Guy, M. and Williams, B. 2023. ‘’A Journal Dedicated to social Equity and Public Administration.’’

Haneda, S., Hashimoto, A. and Tsuneyoshi, T. 2012. ‘’Evaluating adminis-trative efficiency change in the post-merger period: a study on Ibaraki prefecture (1979–2004).’’ International Regional Science Review 35, 2, 237–262.

Hartley, J., Alford, J., Knies, E., & Douglas, S. (2017). Towards an empiri-cal research agenda for public value theory. Public Management Re-view, 670–685.

Kalb, A., Geys, B. and Heinemann, F. 2012. ‘’Value for money? German local government efficiency in a comparative perspective.’’ Applied Economics 44, 2, 201–218.

Lalla M. 2023. ‘’Il disegno della seconda indagine sulle condizioni econom-iche e sociali delle famiglie nella provincia di Modena’’, Università degli studi di Modena, Dipartimento di Economia Politica, CAPP. Centro di Analisi delle Politiche Pubbliche Materiali di discussione n. 512

Lampe, C. 2015. ‘’Trajectories of efficiency measurement: A bibliometric analysis of DEA and SFA.’’

Lo Storto, C. 2013. ‘’Evaluating technical efficiency of Italian major munic-ipalities: a Data Envelopment Analysis model.’’ Procedia Social and Behavioral Sciences 81, 346–350.

Lo Storto, C. 2016. ‘’The trade-off between cost efficiency and public ser-vice quality: a non- parametric frontier analysis of Italian major munici-palities.’’ Cities 51, 52–63.

Loikkanen, H.A. and Susiluoto, I. 2005. ‘’Cost efficiency of Finnish munic-ipalities in basic service provision 1994–2002.’’ Urban Public Econom-ics Review 4, 39–64.

Lorenzo, J.M.P. and Sánchez, I.M.G. 2007. ‘’Efficiency evaluation in mu-nicipal services: an application to the street lighting service in Spain.’’ Journal of Productivity Analysis 27, 3, 149–162.

Lystbaek, CT, Holmgrem, J., & Friis, O. (2021). Perché abbiamo bisogno di strategia nella gestione pubblica? Logiche istituzionali come risorse stra-tegiche nella gestione pubblica. International Public Management Re-view , 21 (2), 1–17.

MacLean, D. and Titah, R. 2022. ‘’A systematic literature review of empiri-cal research on the impacts of e‐government: a public value perspec-tive.’’

Manzoor, A. 2014. ‘’A look at efficiency in public administration: Past and fu-ture.’’

Mihaljević Kosor, M., Malešević Perović, M. and Golem, S. 2019. ‘’Effi-ciency of public spending on higher education: a data envelopment analysis for eu-28.’’

Moore, M. 1995. ‘’Creating Public Value: Strategic Manage-ment in Government.’’ Mussari, R. 2022. ‘’Performance e valore pubblico, CEDAM.’’

Nakazawa, K. 2013. ‘’Cost inefficiency of municipalities after amalgama-tion.’’ Procedia Economics and Finance 5, 581–588.

Nakazawa, K. 2014. ‘’Does the method of amalgamation affect cost ineffi-ciency of the new municipalities?’’ Open Journal of Applied Sciences 4, 4, 143–154.

Narbon Perpina, I. and De Witte, K. 2016. ‘’Local governments efficiency: a systematic literature review.’’

Nikolov, M. and Hrovatin, N. 2013. ‘’Cost efficiency of Macedonian munici-palities in service delivery: does ethnic fragmentation matter?’’ Lex Local-is 11, 3, 743.

Önder, M. and Zengin, ÜN. 2022. ‘’A framework for comparative analysis: Public administration across the globe.’’

Pacheco, F., Sánchez, R. and Villena, M. 2014. ‘’A longitudinal parametric approach to estimate local government efficiency.’’

Papi, L., Ievoli, R., Manzoli, L., Deidda Gagliardo, E., & Gobbo, G. (2021). Performance governance per la generazione di Valore Pubblico in sanità: evidenze empiriche dalle aziende sanitarie dell'Emilia-Romagna. Mecosan: management ed economia sanitaria: 117, 1, 2021, 27-58.

Sami, A., Jusoh, A., Md, N.K., Irfan, I. and Qureshi, M.I. 2018. ‘’Systematic review of public value.’’ Journal of Public Value and Administration In-sights, Vol. 1, No. 1, pp.1–6.

Sampaio de Sousa, M.C., Cribari-Neto, F., Stosic, B.D. 2005. ‘’Explaining DEA technical efficiency scores in an outlier corrected environment: the case of public services in Brazilian municipalities.’’ Brazilian Review of Econometrics 25, 2, 287–313.

Seyedeh L.F.F., Bamdad, S. 2023. ‘’Efficiency measurement of railway passenger stations through network data envelopment analysis.’’

Shi, S. 2023. ‘’The Reform of Human Resource System in the Public Sector under the New Public Management System, SHS Web of Conferences 154, International Conference on Public Service.’’ Economic Manage-ment and Sustainable Development, 11 Jan.

Stastna, L. and Gregor, M. 2011. ‘’Local Government Efficiency: Evidence from the Czech Municipalities.’’ Technical report, Munich University Library, Germany.

Villiers, C., Hsiao, P.K. and Maroun, W., Eds.; Routledge: London, UK; pp. 419–439.

Worthington, A.C. and Dollery, B.E. 2000. ‘’Measuring efficiency in local governments’ planning and regulatory function.’’ Public Productivity & Management Review 29, 2, 469– 485.

Worthington, A.C. and Dollery, B.E. 2001. ‘’Measuring efficiency in local government: an analysis of New South Wales municipalities’ domestic waste management function.’’ Policy Studies Journal 29, 2, 232–249.

Zare, H., Tavana, M., Mardani, A., Masoudian, S., and Kamali Saraji, M. 2019. ‘’A hybrid data envelopment analysis and game theory model for performance measurement in healthcare.’’ Health Care Managament Sci. 2019 Sep;22(3):475-488.

Downloads

Published

2025-06-06

How to Cite

Benvenuto , M., Notarangelo , L., Viola , C., & Aufiero , C. (2025). The efficiency score as an indicator of the appropriateness of public spending. A pilot study in Italian Metropolitan Cities . International Public Management Review, 25(1), 93–132. Retrieved from https://ipmr.net/index.php/ipmr/article/view/496

Issue

Vol. 25 No. 1 (2025)

Section

Articles

License

Authors who publish with this journal agree to the following terms:

1. Authors retain copyright and grant the journal right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License that allows others to share the work for non-commercial use with an acknowledgement of the work's authorship and initial publication in this journal.

2. Authors and IPMR are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the journal's published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository, distribute it via EBSCO, or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgement of its initial publication in this journal.